Variable Speed Drive or Soft Starter?
How to choose the best drive for your application
When managing motors in various applications, selecting the right control device is crucial for optimising performance, efficiency, and longevity. Variable Speed Drives (VSDs) and Soft Starters offer unique benefits for controlling motor speed and startup, respectively. Understanding the differences and applications of these technologies can save energy, reduce maintenance costs, and extend equipment life, making an informed choice essential for both technical and non-technical individuals.
Variable Speed Drives (VSDs)
Variable Speed Drives (VSDs) are a pivotal technology in modern automation and energy efficiency efforts. By precisely controlling the speed of electric motors, VSDs optimise the energy consumption and performance of motor-driven systems. They play a crucial role in a wide array of applications, offering not only significant energy savings but also enhanced process control and reduced wear on equipment.
Benefits
Energy Efficiency
VSDs adjust the motor speed to match the load requirement, significantly reducing energy consumption.
Process Control
They offer precise speed control, improving process control and quality in applications like variable speed pumps.
Extended Equipment Life
By operating motors only at needed speeds, VSDs reduce mechanical stress and wear.
Disadvantages
Complexity and Cost
Higher initial cost and complexity in installation and programming compared to soft starters.
Maintenance Requirements
Potentially higher maintenance and setup expertise needed due to sophisticated electronic components.
Usage Examples
- HVAC systems for variable air volume control.
- Pump applications where flow needs adjustment, like in wastewater treatment plants.
- Conveyor systems where speed variation is required for different phases of operation.
When Not to Use Them
- In applications where the motor does not need to run at variable speeds.
- Where the primary concern is reducing the initial inrush current of a motor rather than controlling its speed (use a softstart).
Technical Considerations
- Compatibility with motor and system power ratings.
- Environment considerations such as dust, moisture, and temperature.
- Harmonic distortion and electrical noise implications.
View our range of Variable Speed Drives.
Soft Starters
Soft Starters provide a gentle ramp-up to full operational speed for electric motors, reducing the stress and strain on both the motor and the electrical supply. This approach minimises the inrush current and the torque shock associated with starting motors, which can lead to extended motor life and lower maintenance costs. Soft Starters are ideal for applications where the primary requirement is to manage the start-up phase efficiently, without the need for speed variation during normal operation.
Benefits
Reduced Startup Current
Limit the inrush current during motor startup, minimising electrical stress and potential system disturbances.
Simple Operation
Easier to install and configure than VSDs, offering a straightforward solution for applications that don’t require speed control.
Cost-Effective
Generally less expensive than VSDs, both in initial investment and maintenance.
Disadvantages
Limited Functionality
Only controls the startup process, without offering ongoing speed control.
Heat Generation
Can generate significant heat during operation, requiring adequate ventilation or cooling.
Usage Examples
- Starting large compressors where the initial inrush current needs to be minimised.
- Applications with motors that drive loads like fans or pumps at a constant speed.
When Not to Use Them
- When precise speed control is necessary during normal operation.
- In applications where energy efficiency is a primary concern through variable speed operation.
Technical Considerations
- Selecting the appropriate size based on the motor’s power rating.
- Understanding the starting torque requirements of the application.
- Environmental conditions that could affect the soft starter’s performance.
Things to Consider When Choosing
Application Requirements
Whether speed control or simply reducing inrush current at startup is needed.
Operational Efficiency
The potential energy savings from operating at variable speeds versus the simplicity and cost of soft starting.
Total Cost of Ownership
Considering both the initial investment and ongoing maintenance costs.
View our range of Soft Starters.
Summary
Contact us for friendly, no obligation advice on selecting the right VSD or soft starter for your project.
Comparison Chart: Variable Speed Drives (VSDs) vs. Soft Starters
VSD vs Softstarts feature comparison
| Feature | Variable Speed Drives (VSDs) | Soft Starters |
| Initial Cost | Higher due to advanced features and control. | Lower, simpler technology. |
| Complexity | Higher, requires setup and programming. | Lower, simpler installation and setup. |
| Speed Control | Full speed control throughout operation. | No speed control after startup. |
| Energy Efficiency | High, adjusts motor speed to load. | Moderate, primarily reduces inrush current. |
| Application Suitability | Best for applications needing variable speeds or precise control. | Best for applications where motors run at a constant speed but need controlled startup. |
| Installation & Setup | More complex, requires technical expertise. | Simpler, easier for basic setups. |
| Maintenance | Potentially higher due to complex electronics. | Generally lower, fewer components at risk. |
| Operational Benefits | Improves process control, extends equipment life by matching speed to demand. | Reduces mechanical and electrical stress during startup, extending motor life. |
| Typical Use Cases | HVAC systems, pump applications, conveyors where speed variation is required. | Large compressors, fans, pumps with constant speed. |
Customer & Supplier Reviews
What people say?
